IELTS Reading practice tests with answers – Set 9
13 questions · Level C1 · Answer them all, then submit to see your score and the explanations.
Maps or Instructions? The Debate over Insect Wayfinding
The question of how a creature with a brain smaller than a grain of rice finds its way across several kilometres of countryside has occupied biologists for well over a century. For much of that time, the answer seemed straightforward: insects, it was assumed, were automata, following fixed sequences of reflexes that carried them from flower to nest without anything resembling thought. That picture has not so much been overturned as complicated, and the more closely researchers examine foraging bees, the less agreement there is about what, exactly, is going on inside their heads. Some components of the system are now reasonably well understood. Bees determine direction largely by reference to the sun, and because the sun moves across the sky during the day, they must compensate for its shifting position using an internal clock. When the sun itself is obscured, they can read the pattern of polarised light in patches of blue sky, detected by a specialised strip of photoreceptors along the upper edge of each compound eye. Distance, meanwhile, appears to be estimated not by counting wingbeats or measuring energy expended, as was once proposed, but by registering the amount of visual motion – what researchers call optic flow – that passes across the eye during flight. The evidence for this last claim is striking: bees trained to fly through narrow tunnels lined with dense patterns behave, on returning to the hive, as if they had travelled much farther than they actually did, presumably because the close, busy walls generated an exaggerated sense of movement. Combining direction and distance allows a bee to perform what is known as path integration: continuously updating an estimate of where home lies relative to its current position, so that after a meandering outward journey it can return in a more or less straight line. Few dispute that bees possess this ability. The controversy begins with the question of what else they possess, and specifically whether they hold anything that deserves to be called a cognitive map – an internal representation of the spatial relationships between multiple places, which would allow an animal to plot novel routes between locations it has never directly connected. Proponents of the map hypothesis point to displacement experiments. In a typical study, bees are captured as they leave the hive, transported in a darkened box to an unfamiliar release point, and tracked by harmonic radar as they find their way back. Many initially fly in the direction their path integrator dictates – that is, as though they had not been moved – but then, after a period of searching, set off on direct courses towards the hive or towards a previously visited feeding site. To advocates, this ability to head straight for a goal from an unfamiliar starting point is precisely what a map would make possible and what a simple chain of memorised routes would not. Sceptics are unconvinced. They argue that the landscapes used in such experiments are rarely as unfamiliar to the bees as the researchers suppose, since a forager may have explored the surrounding area on orientation flights before ever being captured. Moreover, they contend, a bee need not possess a unified map to behave as though it does. It might store a large collection of 'snapshots' – panoramic views of the skyline associated with particular headings – and simply turn until what it sees matches a remembered image. Such view-based guidance, computer simulations suggest, can generate surprisingly efficient homing without any explicit representation of geometry. On this account, the apparent sophistication lies less in the bee than in the richness of the visual world it inhabits. It would be a mistake, however, to treat the debate as a simple contest with a winner yet to be declared. Part of the difficulty is terminological: 'cognitive map' was coined to describe the behaviour of rats in mazes, and researchers apply it to insects with widely differing degrees of strictness. A bee that combines path integration with stored views may achieve, in practice, much of what a map would offer, and whether one chooses to call that combination a map is to some extent a matter of definition rather than discovery. This is not to say the dispute is empty. The two accounts make different predictions – for instance, about whether a bee could take a shortcut between two sites that are not visible from one another – and these predictions can, at least in principle, be tested. What makes such tests difficult is not a shortage of ingenuity but the sheer variability of individual bees. Foragers differ in age, experience and, it seems, temperament; some explore widely, while others return repeatedly to a single patch of flowers. Averaging across dozens of animals may conceal precisely the strategies researchers hope to detect. My own view is that the most productive work in the coming decade will come not from larger experiments but from longer ones, following individual bees across their entire foraging lives to see how their navigational behaviour develops. The stakes extend beyond academic curiosity. Pesticides known as neonicotinoids have been shown in several studies to impair homing at doses below those that cause obvious harm, and urban development continually rearranges the visual landmarks bees rely upon. Understanding which elements of the navigational toolkit are most vulnerable could usefully inform decisions about land use and chemical regulation. It is perhaps a fitting irony that an animal long dismissed as a reflex machine may yet teach us something about how minds of any size make sense of space.
Questions 1–4
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Question 1
In the first paragraph, the writer suggests that the traditional view of insects as automata has been
Question 2
What does the tunnel experiment demonstrate, according to the passage?
Question 3
Why do supporters of the map hypothesis find displacement experiments persuasive?
Question 4
According to the sceptics' snapshot account,
Questions 5–9
Do the following statements agree with the views of the writer in the passage? Write YES, NO or NOT GIVEN.
Question 5
It is now widely accepted that bees can return home by a fairly direct route after an indirect outward flight.
Question 6
The sceptics have been unfair in their criticism of displacement experiments.
Question 7
Researchers who study insects use the term 'cognitive map' in a consistent way.
Question 8
Increasing the number of bees in each experiment is the most promising direction for future research.
Question 9
Research into bee navigation could have practical value for environmental policy.
Questions 10–13
Complete each sentence with the correct ending, A-G, from the box below. Write the correct letter, A-G.
List of Endings
A use the polarisation pattern of blue sky to find direction.
B return home in a roughly straight line after a winding outward flight.
C turn until its current view matches a remembered image.
D help researchers decide between the rival accounts.
E plan new routes between places it has never linked directly.
F hide the strategies that individual foragers actually use.
G judge distance from the energy it has spent during flight.
10 When the sun is hidden from view, bees are able to
11 Path integration allows a bee to
12 According to the snapshot account, a bee may
13 A test of whether bees can take shortcuts between sites not visible from one another could
Answers and explanations
Question 1
No answerIn the first paragraph, the writer suggests that the traditional view of insects as automata has been
Answer: C. made more complex rather than simply rejected.
The writer says the old picture "has not so much been overturned as complicated". This means it was made more complex, not simply rejected.
Question 2
No answerWhat does the tunnel experiment demonstrate, according to the passage?
Answer: B. Bees judge distance from the visual motion they perceive.
Distance is estimated by "registering the amount of visual motion" (optic flow). In the tunnels, the busy walls gave an "exaggerated sense of movement", so the bees judged distance by what they saw.
Question 3
No answerWhy do supporters of the map hypothesis find displacement experiments persuasive?
Answer: C. Displaced bees eventually head directly for goals from an unfamiliar place.
Supporters value the "ability to head straight for a goal from an unfamiliar starting point", which they say a map would allow. The bees do this after a period of searching.
Question 4
No answerAccording to the sceptics' snapshot account,
Answer: B. much of the bees' apparent skill derives from their visual surroundings.
The passage says "the apparent sophistication lies less in the bee than in the richness of the visual world it inhabits". So the skill comes largely from the surroundings.
Question 5
No answerIt is now widely accepted that bees can return home by a fairly direct route after an indirect outward flight.
Answer: Yes
The writer says bees can return "in a more or less straight line" and "Few dispute that bees possess this ability". That means it is widely accepted.
Question 6
No answerThe sceptics have been unfair in their criticism of displacement experiments.
Answer: Not Given
The writer reports the sceptics' arguments but never says whether they are fair or unfair. No opinion is given.
Question 7
No answerResearchers who study insects use the term 'cognitive map' in a consistent way.
Answer: No
Researchers apply the term "with widely differing degrees of strictness". So they do not use it consistently.
Question 8
No answerIncreasing the number of bees in each experiment is the most promising direction for future research.
Answer: No
The writer says the best work will come "not from larger experiments but from longer ones". More bees means larger experiments, so the writer disagrees.
Question 9
No answerResearch into bee navigation could have practical value for environmental policy.
Answer: Yes
The writer says understanding bee navigation "could usefully inform decisions about land use and chemical regulation". That is practical value for policy.
Question 10
No answerWhen the sun is hidden from view, bees are able to
Answer: A. use the polarisation pattern of blue sky to find direction.
"When the sun itself is obscured, they can read the pattern of polarised light in patches of blue sky". This is how they find direction.
Question 11
No answerPath integration allows a bee to
Answer: B. return home in a roughly straight line after a winding outward flight.
Path integration lets a bee, "after a meandering outward journey", "return in a more or less straight line".
Question 12
No answerAccording to the snapshot account, a bee may
Answer: C. turn until its current view matches a remembered image.
In the snapshot account, a bee might "simply turn until what it sees matches a remembered image".
Question 13
No answerA test of whether bees can take shortcuts between sites not visible from one another could
Answer: D. help researchers decide between the rival accounts.
The two accounts make different predictions about shortcuts, and these "can, at least in principle, be tested". Such a test could help decide between them.
0 of 13 answered
Practise more IELTS with scoring
Practise at your level (A2–C1), get your score at once, take full mock tests and see your own error profile. Free.
Practise IELTS on the webPractise anywhere on your phone
The PeakScore app for iPhone and iPad: practice by part, mock tests, your error profile. Same account as the website.