IELTS Reading multiple choice practice with answers – Set 3

7 questions · Level C1 · Answer them all, then submit to see your score and the explanations.

When Parks Push People Out: The Uneasy Politics of Urban Greening

Few propositions in contemporary urbanism command as much agreement as the claim that cities need more greenery. Trees lower summer temperatures on streets that would otherwise radiate heat long after sunset; vegetated land absorbs storm water that would overwhelm drains; and a substantial, if methodologically uneven, literature links access to parks with lower rates of anxiety and cardiovascular disease. Municipal governments from Medellín to Seoul have accordingly made tree planting and park creation a centrepiece of their climate strategies. Yet the enthusiasm has obscured an awkward question that researchers have only recently begun to pursue with any rigour: who, exactly, ends up enjoying these improvements? The concern has acquired a name — green gentrification — and its logic is straightforward. A neglected lot or derelict waterfront is transformed into an attractive public amenity; nearby homes become more desirable; landlords raise rents and developers acquire adjacent sites; and the working-class tenants whose neighbourhood was once dismissed as unappealing find that they can no longer afford to stay. In the most pointed version of the argument, advanced by the urban geographer Teodora Vasilescu, the residents who campaigned longest for a cleaner environment are precisely those least likely to benefit from it, since by the time the saplings mature, many of them have moved to cheaper and frequently less green districts on the urban fringe. It would be premature, however, to treat this pattern as an iron law. Much of the supporting evidence is correlational: property prices do tend to climb near new parks, but parks are often sited in areas where investment is already arriving, so disentangling the effect of the greenery from broader market momentum is notoriously difficult. A handful of longitudinal studies have found that small neighbourhood parks produce only marginal changes in rents, while large, design-led projects that attract visitors from across the city are associated with much sharper increases. This caveat is important, and sceptics are right to insist on it. But it would be a mistake to conclude from the ambiguity of the data that displacement is a phantom. The fact that a park may merely accelerate a process already under way is of little comfort to the household that receives an unaffordable lease renewal. If scale matters, then design and ambition may be legitimate levers of policy. Some planners have embraced what has been called a 'just green enough' approach, which favours modest, dispersed interventions — street trees, community gardens, the clean-up of polluted creeks — over spectacular flagship parks. Proponents such as Park Seo-yeon, who has advised several district councils in South Korea, contend that improvements shaped by existing residents are less likely to be marketed as a lifestyle asset to outsiders. Critics counter that the strategy carries an uncomfortable implication: that low-income communities should accept deliberately unambitious amenities in order to protect themselves from the consequences of having good ones. There is some force to this objection, although it arguably mistakes a tactical compromise for a statement of what such neighbourhoods deserve. A more promising response lies not in restraining the greenery but in reshaping the housing market around it. Community land trusts, which remove property from speculative sale, rent stabilisation ordinances, and requirements that a share of new housing near public investments remain affordable have all been proposed as safeguards. What the experience of several cities suggests is that the sequence in which such measures are introduced is decisive. Protections enacted after a park has opened tend to arrive when land values have already risen and when the political coalition that might have demanded them has partly dispersed. Where tenant protections were secured during the planning phase, by contrast, the evidence — limited though it remains — points to considerably lower rates of displacement. None of this amounts to an argument against urban greening. Withholding trees and parks from poorer districts for fear of what they might trigger would simply entrench the inequalities that many cities already display, in which affluent neighbourhoods enjoy both cooler streets and cleaner air. The more pertinent question is whether green investment is treated as an environmental project alone or as one component of a broader commitment to keeping neighbourhoods liveable for the people already living in them. Cities that frame it in the first way may well succeed in planting a great many trees; whether they will have improved the lives of their existing residents is another matter.

Question 1

What is the main point the writer makes in the first paragraph?

Question 2

According to Teodora Vasilescu, the residents who campaigned longest for a cleaner environment

Question 3

What is the writer's attitude towards the point that much of the evidence for green gentrification is correlational?

Question 4

Critics of the 'just green enough' approach argue that it

Question 5

How does the writer respond to the critics' objection to the 'just green enough' approach?

Question 6

What is the main idea of the fifth paragraph?

Question 7

In the final paragraph, the writer concludes that

0 of 7 answered

Practise more IELTS with scoring

Practise at your level (A2–C1), get your score at once, take full mock tests and see your own error profile. Free.

Practise IELTS on the web

Practise anywhere on your phone

The PeakScore app for iPhone and iPad: practice by part, mock tests, your error profile. Same account as the website.

Get the app on the App Store